Books Report. Filled with emotion and sadness, and it gives Thorin that one final moment of redemption for going mad and becoming an ass. Relevance. Thorin is more sympathetic in Peter Jackson’s “Hobbit” than in J.R.R. In the book, Thorin dies by what is assumed to be some stray arrows and he's found dead on the battlefield. This is not what a heroic leader does. 195. At this point, Peter Jackson has taken a step beyond "adaptation" and is now using Tolkein's book as a springboard to tell his own story. 210. I need to know in detail and in paragraph form in order how the dragon smaug is killed in the book the hobbit. Relevance. Also Radagast is a Maia so he s not going to die. What difference does it make? He is entirely discouraged by the whole turn of affairs. Therefore, because of the connection between the Necromancer and Smaug, it is likely that their communication led to Smaug knowing the name Oakenshield. Virtues of a heroic leader was something that Thorin didn’t possess. Yeah, all three die in the book: Thorin, Kili, & Fili. 3 Answers. Anyone familiar with the story knows how Thorin’s part plays out and I suspect that his final scene in the movies will be emotionally wrenching. Thorin died in the 18th chapter 'The Return Journey' on page 266. Summary and Analysis Chapter 18 - The Return Journey Thorin is buried with the Arkenstone and Orcrist; Kili and Fili, who also died in battle, are buried, too. In The Hobbit films, Gandalf only learns of the Necromancer when he speaks to Radagast, which is what Peter Jackson uses as the reason for Gandalf leaving Thorin and company. Tolkien’s book. They've made him a bit younger than in the book, but I also answer it in my mind by saying they've kept a visual similarity between Kili, Fili and Thorin. How to solve: How did Thorin die in The Hobbit? We see his master is none other than Azog the Defiler. Eh, in the book, as you said Thorin, Fili and Kili dies, it doesnt say how exactly, later Gandalf tells Bilbo in a summary of events. False. There is a sense that an entire way of living in the world is buried with him. So can anybody help me? Bilbo himself does not suffer such a fate, but neither will he be commemorated as a hero. Thorin is killed while commanding the allied armies of Men, Dwarves and Elves during the Battle of Five Armies. Film: As does The Fellowship of the Ring, this film opens with a prologue. When Thorin and his right hand men run up the hill to take out what they assume is the last of the orc army, they fall right into a trap. I was wondering what page Thorin died. (be specific) Raven. By signing up, you'll get thousands of step-by-step solutions to your homework questions. Lv 4. Thorin is brave and intelligent and his leadership of the dwarves is unchallenged; Kili and Fili are especially loyal to him and eventually die with him in the Battle of Five Armies. Well done PJ. But honor and loyalty are still vitally important to Thorin. 8. In celebration of the unlikely adventurer who started J.R.R. A Dwarf Lord known for his wise counsel and willingness to listen, he was one of Thorin's closest friends and advisers. What happens is, Thorin is retrieved from the battle field, in the book, and is badly injured and is on the verge of death and Bilbo comes and they have that … However, a couple of web media outlets have picked it up so somewhat reluctantly here we are quashing a rumour that simply has no credence at all. However, in the book, Gandalf is already well aware of the Necromancer. Ashley Brown. The Movie: At Weathertop, the pack of orcs and wargs that had chased Thorin's Company earlier congregate and discuss their hunt. Balin was distantly related to him, and a descendant of the noble house of Durin. Saeed Ul Hassan. Thorin Oakenshield fights for his family and his home, which he gains back with the help of a hobbit and the people of Lake Town. Moreover, how did Thorin die in The Hobbit? The day after Bilbo gives him the Arkenstone, Bard, the elves, and an old, cloaked man march to the Gate of the Lonely Mountain to greet Thorin.They ask him if he will bargain with them for some of the treasure. Yazneg, the orc who had previously led the pack, apologizes to his master for the dwarves' escape. I knew it was in the 13th chapter but don't know which page. Herein, how does smaug know Thorin is called Oakenshield? In the prologue which flashes back to the Sack of Erebor, Thorin is shown to be a natural leader, and is distressed when Thranduil and his army do not come to the Dwarves' aid. Answer Save. The narrative needed a conflict that would serve as the motivation for Bilbo’s next adventure, which was to rescue the Dwarves and help them get underway again. Favorite Answer. Thorin Oakenshield, the leader of the band of dwarves hoping to regain the treasure under the mountain, is killed in the Battle of the Five Armies. There is no Tauriel in the book. 10 years ago. He died from wounds inflicted in the battle at the Lonely Mountain. Bilbo got back every single one of his possessions when he returned to the Shire. He makes a mistake, however, when he refuses to parley with Bard on the eve of the battle. Bilbo shows a great interest in becoming rich throughout the story. How did Thorin die? Once you understand this logic, you can understand why this decision was made. Bilbo, for his part, would gladly share the treasure. Thorin, however, does have streaks of gray in his black hair. 20. Bolg dies in BoFA and Smaug dies in Lake Town. Thorin comments that if more of the contentious warriors of the world lived the way hobbits do, it would be a happier world, and Bilbo’s return to Hobbiton seems an acknowledgment of the same idea. Book: These events are related by the narrator, Gandalf and Thorin during the “unexpected party” at Bilbo’s home. In the movie, Thorins death is executed beautifully. 6 Answers. Bard gives Thorin some time to reconsider, but Thorin will not change his position. Yes. Does Thorin regret his greed before he dies and recognize his mistakes? They all appear a bit more human than dwarven. Sean Bean may have to share “best death scene” with Richard Armitage — or maybe Richard will take that glory from him. This scene is not in the book, and adds a violent battle that somewhat changes the tone of the scene. When Thorin dies, however, Dain celebrates all those who were crucial in destroying the enemy, including presenting Lake-Town with Bilbo's 1/14th share of the reward. Thorin is buried as a hero, with his treasured jewel and his sword, accompanied in death as he was in life by his loyal companions Kili and Fili. No, Thorin is not a heroic leader. Furthermore, Thorin made bad choices, was weak, and gave in to greed. Assuming dwarves are simply more compact humans, that would probably move his heart up a bit. Roac is a _____ with special powers of speech. Additionally, what chapter does Thorin die in The Hobbit? 1 decade ago . 1. Anonymous. Bilbo narrates the story of how the dwarves were driven out of their mountain home Erebor by the dragon Smaug after finding the Arkenstone. 150. 250 « … But Thorin is a dwarf, not a human. Since Thorin is still alive but nearing death when Bilbo finds him, this would fit well with the assumption that this is a stomach wound. He was one of thethirteen Dwarves who accompanied Thorin II Oakenshield on the quest to regain the Lonely Mountain. The hero of the book is Bilbo, not Thorin, hence the title. The quest may be about Thorin, or the dwarves in general, taking back the mountain but the book is not. One can imagine how Thorin could have been more diplomatic, or how the Elvenking could have tried again to speak with Thorin, but I think that would weaken the narrative structure of the story. This is from LOTR wiki: During a confrontation with the dragon, Baggins noticed one missing scale on the monster's left breast, nearest his heart. Click to see full answer. He reclaims the Lonely Mountain and its treasure, but does not live long enough to enjoy it. In fact, as others have stated, it adds quite a bit. Source(s): … How old is Thorin? After a prolonged fight, Thorin and Azog mortally wound each other, and Thorin dies in Bilbo's arms. The Book: There is no such scene. A significant theme in The Hobbit is Thorin paying a high price for his pride. Yup, all three of them die in the book just like it happened in the movie....of course, in a different way. Those wounds lead to lots of internal bleeding and take a while to kill you. Thror and Thrain were already dead before the book's timeframe begins. (The Hobbit Novel) What page did Thorin die? If they don’t die doing that, then they live in the halls of their fathers which is greater than the living in peace option. Favorite Answer . How Well do You Know Thorin Oakenshield? Answer Save. 4 years ago. One of the things I dislike most about the Hobbit films is that the dwarves do not look like dwarves. In the first movie, we see that Thorin earns his name 'Oakenshield' during the Battle of Azanulbizar (Moria), which is after they have fled from Smaug and Erebor. 0 0. bowker. Probably the only twist that those who didn't read the book saw coming before those who did. Thorin is just a secondary character and his death does not ruin the story. Frankly, we hoped this story would die a quiet death because it is simply not credible. Gimli is a fictional character from J. R. R. Tolkien's Middle-earth legendarium, featured in The Lord of the Rings.A dwarf warrior, he is the son of Glóin, a member of Thorin's company in Tolkien's earlier book The Hobbit.. Gimli is chosen to represent the race of Dwarves in the Fellowship of the Ring.As such, he is one of the primary characters of the novel. Balin was a Dwarf leader, the son of Fundin, and elder brother of Dwalin. My guess for the films is, they may not even include Bolg other than as a cameo appereance. Kili and Fili die and Thorin dies, get over it, it's important in the grand scheme of storytelling and is common in the sort of saga that the legacy of The Hobbit is a part of. Tolkien's epic Lord of the Rings adventure, this is the Bilbo Baggins story, explained. The mountain is declared besieged: nothing and no one will be let in or out if elves and men can help it. The Hobbit Thorin Dies. Thorin lacks the virtues of loyalty, honor, dignity, and commitment to the cause. – BBlake Jan 13 '15 at 17:50. You could be cynical and say they wanted the "hot" dwarves to be less exaggerated. Heroism is important in a world beset with evil, but Tolkien suggests that if everyone lived the simple life of hobbits, evil would be obsolete. This changes the events of the book a great deal. From beginning to end, Throin’s motivation was self preservation. Add to library 1 » Discussion 3 » Follow author » Share .